Karita Mattila in Recital at the Canary Islands Music Festival
By Robert Hilferty

The fabulous soprano starts out at less than her best (singing less-than-excellent material), but finishes in a blaze of glory with songs by Duparc and Strauss.


Karita Mattila (soprano)
Tuija Hakkila (piano)

Friday 1 February 2002
Teatro Guimera, Santa Cruz de Tenerife, Canary Islands (Spain)
Presented by the XVIII Festival de Música de Canarias

Schubert:
     Non t'accostar all'urna
     La Pastorella
     Mio ben ricordati
     Aria "Vedi quanto adoro" (D. 510)
Mahler: 
     Frulingsmorgen
     Errinnerung
     Hans und Grethe
Sibelius: 
     Var det en drorn, Op. 37, No. 4
     Demanten po marssnon, Op. 36, No. 6
     Flickan kom ifran sin alsklings mote, Op. 37, No. 5
Duparc: 
     L'invitation au voyage
     Phidlye
     Chanson triste
Strauss: 
     "Morgen", Op. 27, No. 4
     "O süsser Mai", Op. 32, No. 4
     "Schön sind, doch kalt die Himmelssterne", Op. 19, No. 3
     "Meinem Kinde", Op. 37, No. 3
     "Cäcilie", op. 27, No. 2


The first part of Karita Mattila's recital in Teatro Guimera was far from spectacular. She started off with Schubert's Italian songs. A curious cluster in his canon, they are not up to his best Lieder, but interesting because the composer seems to be nodding to his musical neighbors to the south and making a good stab at quasi-bel canto. But only the last of those songs here, the recitative and aria Didone Abbandonata: "Vedi quanto t'adoro" (to a text by renowned opera seria poet Pietro Metastasio) has any real musical worth. The piece recalls a kind of Haydnesque dramatic aesthetic, and Mattila projected all the Sturm und Drang of the beleaguered heroine magnificently. A handful of unextraordinary early Mahler songs followed, mostly of the cute and sentimental variety. Mattila was more at home with the Sibelius section, especially the poignant and complex "Flickan kom ifran sin alskilings mote," to a poem in Swedish by Johan Ludvig Runeberg, the Finnish "national poet." The drama-in-miniature recounts a conversation between mother and daughter about her lover, and Mattila gave an astounding performance.

The second half was markedly better, in terms of both musical substance and the quality of Mattila's voice (which, admittedly, suffered slightly in the first half because of the dryness of the auditorium). In fact, she made a costume change during intermission (from chic, Phrygian black to a blindingly bright floral print), and a line from the opening Duparc song, "L'Invitation au voyage", sums up her presence and the excellence of the rest of the performance: "Là, tout n'est qu'ordre et beauté, lux, calme et volupté." Her delivery of this line was exquisite, the timbre of her voice velvety, the control impeccable. She handled the dynamic extremes of "Phydle" with seamless artistry, and with "Chanson triste" she had the audience on the verge of tears, especially upon hitting the touching high note on the word "mon" of "mon amour."

Unbelievably, things went from perfection to superperfection with the last Strauss set. "Morgen" was lovely, Mattila's melting tones bringing vividly to mind the sunrise imagined in the text; her effulgence was irrepressible in "O süsser Mai." With "Meinem Kinde" musical and maternal instincts were wedded in one of the most gorgeous lullabies ever written, Mattila soaring magnificently on the word "Sternein." With "Cäcilie", as in the preceding songs, Mattila's ability to sculpt every phrase and enounce every nuance with her superbly expressive instrument was eminently on display. The audience was on its feet at the end.


© andante Corp. March 2002. All rights reserved.
 

concert reviews
news
concert reviews
CD reviews
interviews
perspectives
essays
book reviews
calendar